PB Sandwich Cookies Chris Sutherland Eastpointe, MI My Grandmother Ann taught my dad this recipe. One day he made a batch with my 2-year old daughter Victoria. It took me 45 minutes to scrape the peanut butter off everything in my kitchen, including my dad and my daughter. . . they laughed and laughed! I am so glad that my dad is keeping my grandmother's legacy alive. 16-oz. pkg. powdered sugar 28-oz. jar creamy peanut butter 1 c. milk 16-oz. pkg. graham crackers Mix together the powdered sugar and milk in a bowl, Add three- fourths of the peanut butter; mix well. Add more peanut butter if necessary to make a pasty consistency. Spread mixture on half of a graham cracker and top with the other half, making a sandwich. The number of cookies made will depend on how much you spread on each cracker.